Connect with us


Why Have We Given Up on Albert Pujols?

When one of the greatest hitters of all-time is still around, why are we shutting him out?

Albert Pujols by Dave Herholz is licensed under CC BY SA-2.0

Why Have We Given Up on Albert Pujols?

Estimated Reading Time: 8 Minutes

On August 4th, 2010, Alex Rodriguez took Shaun Marcum deep at Yankee Stadium for his 600th home run, 3 years to the day of his induction into the 500 club. With the 2,633rd hit of his career, the Yankee third baseman was 35-years old, making him the youngest player to ever join the small handful of men who have hit 600 home runs. It was a moment, something you can only see a handful of times.

The most recent name added to the select few to have hit 600 home runs is Albert Pujols. Almost seven years later, on June 3rd, 2017, the 37-year-old Pujols crushed a pitch from Ervin Santana over the left-field wall for a Grand Slam. The ballpark seemed empty, the game held no weight, and the fanfare was minimal.

That’s a goddamn shame.

What Albert Pujols did on that Saturday in 2017 is something only the greats can do. Hitting 600 home runs is not easy. In fact, I’d venture to say it’s pretty damn hard to do. So why was there relatively little celebration? Why didn’t this moment matter?

Buster Olney had an idea.

“I think it is because the number has been diminished by all the players who have reached it, really, in the last 15 years.  If you think about it, for decades, the 600-home run club included three people: Hank Aaron and Babe Ruth and Willie Mays. And year after year after year it was those three guys. Then in 2002, Barry Bonds became the fourth and five others have joined since then. And so I think it got watered down. Certainly, the fact that some of the players who have joined the 600-home run club since — Alex Rodriguez, Sammy Sosa, Barry Bonds — have been linked to steroids, I think have hurt that number as well. And everybody who has joined that club now, it is not as exclusive as it once was.”

I think Buster is right… for the most part. With players like A-Rod, Sammy Sosa, and Barry Bonds in the 600 club, it has lost its luster. No longer is it only revered legends like Babe Ruth, Hank Aaron, and Willie Mays. Now we’ve also got some questionable individuals in there. That surely is a dark mark on the legacy of the 600 Home Run Club.

But I beg to differ on the “watered down” part of his comments. I don’t think Sosa and Bonds did that. In fact, I believe we did. We’re responsible for letting that happen.

I wrote a whole article a while back about steroid use in baseball. Check it out here. Take a look, but I’ll give you a brief synopsis. We used to have a huge steroid problem in baseball. Yes, we still have a steroid issue, but even more so, we have a perceived stigma about the players in the steroid era. Mike Piazza, the best home run hitting catcher of all time, was not a first-ballot Hall of Famer due to some steroid speculation. SPECULATION. When asked about it during his 2016 Hall of Fame Media call, he was again asked about it. Even after he was in the Hall, there were still questions.

The year before Piazza was voted into Cooperstown, Bill Madden of the New York Daily News had this to say:

“They said he did steroids. It was a number of players — in their opinion, or whatever … Bottom line is, there were players in the major leagues who played against him — I can’t remember if there was anybody who played with him — and it was more than just one or two that definitively said, in their opinion, he did steroids. These players weren’t saying this about anybody else. So, I mean, I always had my doubts about Piazza, even though there was no positive testing and he wasn’t listed in the Mitchell Report. And my feeling was, I’m gonna withhold my vote, and I’ll give you a reason for that — the classic example being Alex Rodriguez. Here was a guy that told everybody he never did steroids, and then he confesses to the feds that he did do steroids his entire career.”

Read that again.

Basically, his thought process is this: ‘They said he did it, these guys said it although there is no proof, it’s their opinion. So it’s also mine, and because of that, he doesn’t get in. He could be lying. A-Rod.’ That’s a terrible mentality to have about players. There’s no benefit of the doubt given to players who were clean and played through the steroid era.

That’s where Pujols comes in. The 2001 Rookie of the Year broke onto the scene in a big way, by crushing 37 homers and slashing .329/.403/.610, with an OPS of 1.013. What followed was a decade of production that was seemingly unmatched by any other player. Seriously. Pujols placed outside of the top 5 for MVP only once in those 10 years, he only hit below .300 once in those ten years, and never failed to hit 30+ home runs.

Over the first ten seasons of his MLB Career, Pujols never had an OPS+ below 150. Other players who cannot say the same include Willie Mays, Hank Greenberg, Stan Musial, Ty Cobb, Mickey Mantle, Rogers Hornsby, Joe DiMaggio, Barry Bonds, Hank Aaron, and Babe Ruth.

Albert Pujols’ career average is .308 despite hitting below .300 since 2010, prior to that point, his average never dipped below the .300 line. The man was a hitting machine, plain and simple.

As of today, Pujols has amassed a career WAR of 100.8, good enough for 20th on the all-time list. All of those incredible numbers make Pujols one of the all-time greats, and yet, as he accomplished one of the all-time career milestones, he’s met with very little fanfare.


Did Pujols deserve to be quietly celebrated? Absolutely not. If anything, Pujols is a champion of what a ballplayer can do when not using performance-enhancing drugs. But there’s still that doubt, isn’t there? In the back of your mind, just sitting there saying… “can’t be sure either way.”

When Pujols was accused of using PEDs by ex-player Jack Clark, he took legal action and sued Clark for defamation. Pujols dropped the lawsuit and Clark apologized, but the damage was done. Pujols and PEDs have now been connected out in the open and that would be enough for people’s minds to be made up. That’s not okay.

Did Pujols wrong the Cardinals by leaving town? No. He did what every young player is doing nowadays, waiting for that big paycheck and cashing in. I mean, when offered the largest baseball contract at the time, you take it. Could he have won another ring in St. Louis? Maybe, but he’s already got two.

Pujols has also been a great role model off the field. The Pujols Family Foundation is a non-profit organization that promotes awareness of Down Syndrome as well as working to support those who have it and their families. The Foundation also aids the poor in the Dominican Republic and supports people with disabilities and/or life-threatening illnesses. Pujols’ strength and love is not just something he keeps on the field.

Sure there has been a drop in his numbers since he turned 30 and left St. Louis. Foot injuries have taken their toll on Pujols and greatly hampered his ability to be the player he once was. Pujols still has some fight left in him, or else why would he still be suiting up every night.

The guy is one of the greatest to play the game, but we’ve forgotten that.

The MLB has actively been looking for ways to bring more of an audience to the game. Adding game clocks, expanding challenges, removing intentional walks, the “uNiVeRsAl dH”, all in the name of speeding up the game and attracting new fans. Maybe they can focus on other issues like fixing the public perception of their players.

If there was a 50/50 chance that Steph Curry was somehow cheating from the three-point line, I’m sure the NBA would fix the issue. Whereas the MLB is just going to let the public’s minds run wild, while innocent bystanders of the era get dragged through the mud. Pujols did nothing to have his achievement soiled by the actions and choices of others. Yet here we are, with one of the all-time greats wondering why no one’s celebrating.

It’s an odd, deafening silence.

After the 1994-95 Players strike, MLB was in a tough spot. No one came out of the strike on the fans’ good side. Frankly, it seemed like a miracle was needed to regain the fans’ trust and admiration. Luckily for MLB, Cal Ripken was close to breaking Lou Gehrig’s 56-year old consecutive game streak. By leaning on the amazing streak and how magical the game of baseball is, MLB was able to grab the fans back relatively quickly. There’s something nostalgic and historic about this game, and that aspect is something other professional sports don’t have.

Eleven months after his 600th home run, Pujols knocked a single to right in a game against Seattle. Albert Pujols was now the fourth player in the history of the game to have hit 600 home runs and notch 3,000 hits. Was there any kind of pomp and circumstance? Did his 3,000th hit fall like a tree in a forest with no one around to hear it? You be the judge.

Maybe Buster Olney is right, it’s lonely at the top, but there’s plenty of scrutiny to go around, whether it’s deserved or not.

Justin Colombo is a 2017 Broadway Show Softball League All-Star at 3B/SS. He's essentially the Manny Machado of the Kinky Boots team. Justin has been writing about Baseball since he was a little kid. Now that being an actor in NYC has given him a lot of free time, in 2015 he decided to take his passion public and founded Three Up, Three Down as a way to express his love for the game. From there, Three Up, Three Down grew from a hobby to an obsession. After years of growth and one insult from MLB's Historian, Justin launched The Turf, a way to expand into all areas of the sporting world. Follow him on Instagram and Twitter. LET'S. GO. METS.



    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


    Editor’s Picks

    Latest Articles